The CSG Actuarial Premium Rate Scorecard™ provides an overall premium rate competitiveness ranking by company across all states, plans, ages, genders, households, and zip codes, based on actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed on CSG Actuarial’s Market Advisor quoting tools.
Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in November 2019, the 15 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies as of December 1, 2019 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are
| Rank | All Plans | Plan F | Plan G | Plan N |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Southern Guaranty | Southern Guaranty | Southern Guaranty | Catholic Life |
| 2 | Atlantic Coast Life | Catholic Life | State Mutual | Central States |
| 3 | Catholic Life | State Mutual | Catholic Life | Southern Guaranty |
| 4 | State Mutual | Lumico | Lumico | Atlantic Coast Life |
| 5 | Central States | Prosperity Life | Atlantic Coast Life | Prosperity Life |
| 6 | Lumico | Americo | Central States | Equitable Group |
| 7 | Prosperity Life | Guarantee Trust | Prosperity Life | Puritan Life |
| 8 | Assurant | Humana | Equitable Group | Aetna |
| 9 | Equitable Group | Assurant | Assurant | Lumico |
| 10 | Guarantee Trust | Aetna | Old Surety | Assurant |
| 11 | Aetna | Pan American | Humana | State Mutual |
| 12 | Americo | Equitable Group | Manhattan Group | Pan American |
| 13 | Pan American | Puritan Life | Guarantee Trust | Guarantee Trust |
| 14 | Humana | Erie Life | Pan American | Humana |
| 15 | Puritan Life | National Guardian | Aetna | Manhattan Group |