The CSG Actuarial Premium Rate Scorecard™ provides an overall premium rate competitiveness ranking by company across all states, plans, ages, genders, households, and zip codes, based on actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed on CSG Actuarial’s Market Advisor quoting tools.
Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in January 2021, the 15 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies for all plans combined as of February 1, 2021 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are:
| Rank | Company |
|---|---|
| 1 | United States Fire |
| 2 | American Financial Security Life Insurance Company |
| 3 | State Mutual |
| 4 | Manhattan Life Group |
| 5 | Independence American |
| 6 | Liberty Life Group |
| 7 | Royal Arcanum |
| 8 | Atlantic Coast Life |
| 9 | Central States |
| 10 | United Insurance Company of America |
| 11 | Accendo |
| 12 | Catholic Life |
| 13 | Federal Life Insurance Company |
| 14 | Lumico |
| 15 | Erie Family Life |
Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in January 2021, the 15 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies for Plan F as of February 1, 2021 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are:
| Rank | Company |
|---|---|
| 1 | American Financial Security Life Insurance Company |
| 2 | Nassau Life |
| 3 | Accendo |
| 4 | Central States |
| 5 | Royal Arcanum |
| 6 | Manhattan Life Group |
| 7 | Independence American |
| 8 | Liberty Life Group |
| 9 | Federal Life Insurance |
| 10 | State Mutual |
| 11 | United States Fire |
| 12 | Physicians Life |
| 13 | United Insurance Company of America |
| 14 | Catholic Life |
| 15 | WMI Mutual Insurance Company |
Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in January 2021, the 15 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies for Plan G as of February 1, 2021 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are:
| Rank | Company |
|---|---|
| 1 | United States Fire |
| 2 | State Mutual |
| 3 | Independence American |
| 4 | Manhattan Life Group |
| 5 | Liberty Life Group |
| 6 | United Insurance Company of America |
| 7 | American Financial Security Life Insurance Company |
| 8 | Atlantic Coast Life |
| 9 | Old Surety |
| 10 | Catholic Life |
| 11 | Erie Family Life |
| 12 | Central States |
| 13 | Lumico |
| 14 | Accendo |
| 15 | Federal Life Insurance |
Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in January 2021, the 15 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies for Plan N as of February 1, 2021 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are:
| Rank | Company |
|---|---|
| 1 | American Financial Security Life Insurance Company |
| 2 | Manhattan Life Group |
| 3 | United States Fire |
| 4 | Catholic Life |
| 5 | Liberty Life Group |
| 6 | Federal Life Insurance |
| 7 | Accendo |
| 8 | Independence American |
| 9 | State Mutual |
| 10 | Royal Arcanum |
| 11 | Central States |
| 12 | Nassau Life |
| 13 | Atlantic Coast Life |
| 14 | Southern Guaranty |
| 15 | Aetna |